Discover the Top 15 Best-Selling Butter Candy Options Available Now

If you’re a forever fan of butter candy, then we’re sure you’ll agree with our list of 15 top-selling butter-flavored candies! 

Many of you know us, but for those who don’t, we have several decades in the candy business, so we got the drop when it comes to what’s hot and what’s not! 

In this guide, we’re shining a light on the most irresistible butter candy options currently captivating candy lovers nationwide! 

Indeed, we aim to ensure that you have easy access to your favorite candies. Each product that we feature here in this list is available for immediate purchase. 

We also understand the importance of getting your candy quickly, so we’ve streamlined the process! So, find a candy that captures your fancy and click to add it directly to your cart.

We also pride ourselves on our competitive pricing! When you shop with us, you get top-quality candy at prices that are hard to beat elsewhere. This is our commitment to you!

We’re excited to share this list with you and can’t wait to hear your thoughts. Did your all-time favorite butter candy make our list? Let us know! 

Your input is crucial and helps us keep our selections fresh and exciting. Thank you for joining us today as we discuss all the best-selling butter candies currently available right now! 

The Top 15 Best-Selling Butter Candy List

Here it is! Presenting the ultimate list of butter candy, the best compilation you’ll find anywhere online. 

We’ve done our homework, and it’s clear that no other list matches our thoroughness and appeal. Below, we proudly showcase our top-selling butter-flavored candies available here at Candy Retailer!

Each item on this list has a fresh, up-to-date image, detailed product information, and a handy ‘Order Here’ button for immediate purchase. 

And remember, just because your preferred candy isn’t on today’s list doesn’t mean it’s not in our store.

For a broader selection, be sure to explore our extensive range of butter candies; we likely have what you’re looking for! Click the link to browse our entire collection of butter candies and find your new or old favorites!

Colombina Butter Cream Toffee Hard Candy

This hard candy is packaged in a 1lb bag and offers a rich butter cream toffee flavor. Experience the traditional taste of Colombina Butter Cream Toffee. Get yours now for a classic treat.

Colombina Butterscotch Buttons

These candies come in a convenient 1lb pack. Colombina Butterscotch Buttons are known for their smooth texture and rich flavor. Order today and savor the timeless taste.

Edas Sugar-Free Hard Candy Butterscotch

Offered in a 1lb package, this sugar-free option delivers the classic butterscotch flavor without the added sugar. Enjoy Edas Butterscotch, guilt-free. Click to add to your cart.

Gilliam Old Fashioned Candy Sticks Butterscotch

Containing 80 sticks per box, these candy sticks blend a nostalgic design with a delightful butterscotch flavor. Try Gilliam’s Old Fashioned Sticks for a trip down memory lane. Purchase your box today.

Harry Potter Butterbeer Barrel Tins

Each tin weighs 1.5oz and features the unique Butterbeer flavor inspired by the Harry Potter series. Add a magical twist to your day with Harry Potter Butterbeer Barrel Tins. Grab your tin now.

Harry Potter Butterbeer Chewy Candy

This chewy candy comes in a 2.1oz pack, bringing the enchanting Butterbeer taste to a chewy form. Experience the magic of Harry Potter Butterbeer Chewy Candy. Order your pack immediately.

Harry Potter Butterbeer Glass Mug

The 8oz glass mug offers a non-edible but themed treat for Harry Potter and Butterbeer fans alike. Complete your collection with the Harry Potter Butterbeer Glass Mug. Secure yours today.

Jelly Belly Buttered Popcorn

Available in various sizes, Jelly Belly offers the unique buttered popcorn flavor in jelly bean form. Discover the surprising taste of Jelly Belly Buttered Popcorn. Pick your size and order now.

Jelly Belly Buttered Popcorn Cart Bean Machine

This item delivers not just the candy but an engaging way to dispense it. Enjoy the fun of Jelly Belly Buttered Popcorn with this unique bean machine. Get your Bean Machine today.

Jelly Belly Jelly Beans Buttered Popcorn

Packaged in a 1lb bag, these jelly beans combine the fun of Jelly Belly with a buttered popcorn twist. Dive into the unique flavor of Jelly Belly Jelly Beans Buttered Popcorn. Add to your collection now.

Nips Butter Rum Hard Candy

This 3.25oz bag of hard candy blends a smooth butter rum flavor in a classic hard candy form. Savor the richness of Nips Butter Rum Hard Candy. Click to purchase.

Primrose Butterscotch Buttons

Available in a 1lb package, these butterscotch buttons offer a classic, rich taste. Enjoy the simple pleasure of Primrose Butterscotch Buttons. Order your bag today.

Quality Candy Butterscotch Discs

These discs come in a 1lb pack, providing a traditional butterscotch experience. Experience the quality of Quality Candy Butterscotch Discs. Add to your cart now.

Taffy Town Buttered Popcorn Salt Water Taffy

Offered in a 1lb bag, this salt water taffy brings the unique buttered popcorn flavor to a chewy taffy texture. Indulge in the unique blend of Taffy Town Buttered Popcorn Salt Water Taffy. Purchase here.

Edas Sugar-Free Hard Candy Butter Rum

Available in a 1lb pack, this sugar-free candy offers the rich taste of butter rum without the sugar. Treat yourself to Edas Sugar-Free Butter Rum Hard Candy. Click here to buy.

Butter Candy Knowledge Quiz

Do you think you’ve got what it takes to be a Butter Candy expert? Are you or someone you know an authority on these smooth, buttery confections? Now’s the time to put that knowledge to the test with our Butter Candy Knowledge Quiz!

Our quiz is a fun and engaging way to learn some fascinating and lesser-known facts about butter candies, ideal for both casual snack lovers and dedicated candy aficionados. From their historical origins to the secrets behind their rich flavors, we have a range of questions to challenge you.

Let’s see how much you really know about these buttery delights! Gear up, get your memory ready, and dive into our quiz. Don’t forget to share your results in the comments and challenge your friends to beat your score!

Question 1

Which historical period is credited with the invention of butterscotch?

A) Victorian Era

B) Middle Ages

C) Renaissance

D) Industrial Revolution

Answer: A) Victorian Era

Question 2

What is the main ingredient that gives butterscotch its distinct flavor?

A) Honey

B) Brown Sugar

C) Maple Syrup

D) Caramel

Answer: B) Brown Sugar

Question 3

Which type of traditional treat is butter rum candy often associated with?

A) Licorice

B) Taffy

C) Hard Candy

D) Gummies

Answer: C) Hard Candy

Question 4

In what form was the first commercial butter toffee candy sold?

A) Bars

B) Drops

C) Sticks

D) Balls

Answer: B) Drops

Question 5

Which U.S. state is known for producing saltwater taffy, including butter-flavored varieties?

A) California

B) New Jersey

C) Florida

D) Texas

Answer: B) New Jersey

Question 6

What ingredient in butter candy is often replaced in sugar-free varieties?

A) Butter

B) Sugar

C) Flavoring

D) Salt

Answer: B) Sugar

Question 7

Which of these is a classic feature of traditional butterscotch candy?

A) Nutty flavor

B) Creamy texture

C) Chewy consistency

D) Crystalline structure

Answer: D) Crystalline structure

Question 8

Butter mints, a type of butter candy, are traditionally served in which setting?

A) Movie Theaters

B) Birthday Parties

C) Weddings

D) Sports Events

Answer: C) Weddings

Question 9

What is the key difference between butterscotch and caramel?

A) Cooking temperature

B) Main ingredient

C) Color

D) Texture

Answer: A) Cooking temperature

Question 10

Which European country is famed for its butter candies, particularly toffees and caramels?

A) France

B) Italy

C) Germany

D) United Kingdom

Answer: D) United Kingdom

Navigating Our Selection of Butter Candy Made Easy and Fun

Embarking on your butter candy adventure just got more thrilling! Grab this opportunity to replenish your stock of cherished butter-flavored candies and enjoy some great savings while you’re at it.

We value your time exploring our guide and hope you found it insightful and enjoyable. Don’t hesitate to engage in our community dialogues – we’d love to hear about your preferred candy flavor in the comments below!